Updated
Updated · Geo News · Jun 22
Halsey Blasts 3 Million-Subscriber Critic Anthony Fantano Over 2024 Album Review
Updated
Updated · Geo News · Jun 22

Halsey Blasts 3 Million-Subscriber Critic Anthony Fantano Over 2024 Album Review

3 articles · Updated · Geo News · Jun 22

Summary

  • Sunday’s X posts saw Halsey unleash a scathing rebuttal after Anthony Fantano said his review of her 2024 album “The Great Impersonator” was more interesting than the record itself.
  • Fantano had called the album “the worst case of main character syndrome” on a review first shared to his 3 million subscribers more than a year ago, prompting Halsey to argue he mocked a work about medical suffering.
  • Halsey said she had “the excuse of going through chemo” while making the album, which drew on her lupus and T-cell lymphoproliferative disorder and nearly fatal health struggles.
  • She framed the clash as bigger than one bad review, saying Fantano’s comments reinforced women’s fears that speaking openly about serious illness will be dismissed as attention-seeking.

Insights

Does an artist's real-life trauma make their work about that trauma immune from harsh criticism?
Is 'main character syndrome' a valid artistic critique or a modern tool to dismiss women's pain?