The Athletic Ranks 50 World Cup Players, Putting Dembele Ahead of Kane and Messi

Q: With legends Messi and Ronaldo ranked low, which football giant is most likely to suffer a shocking group stage exit?

Portugal looks the most vulnerable among the traditional heavyweights. The case is straightforward: the same material that notes Cristiano Ronaldo’s low, “legacy pick” ranking also flags Portugal as one of the six main contenders most exposed to an early stumble. The concern is structural as much as symbolic. Portugal still has elite talent — Vitinha is ranked fifth and Gonçalo Ramos is a strong alternative up front — but the team’s ceiling and balance are still tied to a 41-year-old Ronaldo whose impact now depends heavily on how selflessly he plays. Argentina is also mentioned as vulnerable because of an aging core around Lionel Messi, but the broader evidence is kinder to the defending champions. Messi, even at 38, remains productive, and Argentina are still projected by some models to top their group. Portugal, by contrast, are the only major favorite in the supplied projections not clearly expected to dominate their section, with one forecast even placing them second behind Colombia. In an expanded 48-team tournament, that kind of uncertainty matters because a giant no longer needs to collapse completely to invite danger. Germany and Brazil have warning signs too — Germany because of its recent World Cup failures, Brazil because of injuries and squad imbalance — but based on the combined reporting, Portugal is the clearest answer if the question is which football giant is most likely to deliver the tournament’s shock group-stage disappointment.

Q: Which rising stars on the list, like Argentina's Nico Paz, are poised for a breakout performance at the World Cup?

Nico Paz looks like one of the clearest breakout candidates. The 21-year-old Argentina midfielder is already on The Athletic’s top-50 list at No. 49, and his club season gives substance to the hype: at Como, he completed more dribbles than any player in Serie A and produced 13 goals and eight assists. That mix of ball-carrying and end product makes him a plausible impact player even in a deep Argentina squad. France may have the richest supply of emerging stars. Desire Doue, ranked No. 29, is specifically highlighted as a rising talent with the tools to influence matches as the tournament unfolds. Michael Olise, already as high as No. 4, is no longer a secret but still feels like a player on the verge of a true global breakthrough; this is his first World Cup, and after a standout Bayern season he could leave the tournament established among France’s elite. Rayan Cherki, though not cited in the ranking summary, is another young French attacker widely viewed as ready for a major international leap. Spain’s Lamine Yamal is already a star, but at 18 he still fits the breakout theme on the biggest stage. Ranked No. 3, he has the profile to turn this tournament into his definitive arrival as one of the world’s best players. Beyond the ranked names, outside breakout-watch lists have also pointed to Nico O’Reilly, Yan Diomande, Luka Vuskovic and Johan Manzambi as young players capable of surprising at this World Cup.

Q: Is Dembele's #1 ranking a data anomaly, or has he truly surpassed consistent superstars like Kane and Mbappe?

Dembélé’s No. 1 ranking looks justified by the model’s criteria, not like a fluke — but it is also a snapshot of peak impact rather than proof he has become the more reliable all-around superstar over time than Harry Kane or Kylian Mbappé. The key is how The Athletic says it built the list: not just talent, but current form, fitness and expected tournament role. On that basis, Dembélé has a strong case. He is the reigning Ballon d’Or winner, was decisive in PSG’s biggest Champions League matches, and his recent output in elite knockout games has been exceptional. The supporting data cited around him — including his leading Champions League knockout-stage goal involvements over the relevant span — points to sustained high-end impact in the matches that matter most. That said, Kane and Mbappé remain stronger examples of week-to-week consistency. Kane’s 61-goal season for Bayern is the clearest volume case in Europe, while Mbappé’s scoring numbers and long-term elite production remain unmatched by most peers. If the question is who has been the most dependable superstar over several seasons, Dembélé still trails them. So the ranking is best read as a form-and-context verdict, not a career hierarchy. Right now, Dembélé’s combination of major-trophy influence, Ballon d’Or recognition and tactical importance for France makes No. 1 defensible. But the gap is narrow, and Kane or Mbappé overtaking him during the World Cup would not be surprising.

3 articles · Updated · The New York Times · Jun 11

Ousmane Dembele tops The Athletic’s provisional top-50 list for the 2026 World Cup, ahead of Harry Kane at No. 2 and Lamine Yamal at No. 3.
The ranking weighs current form, fitness and likely tournament roles rather than pure talent, and will be updated over the next five weeks using a new player-ratings model.
France dominates the upper tier with four of the top 10—Dembele, Michael Olise, Kylian Mbappe and William Saliba—while Portugal places three in the top 10, led by Vitinha at No. 5.
Lionel Messi and Cristiano Ronaldo still make the cut at Nos. 25 and 50, reflecting their enduring influence but also questions over age, pressing and how much they can still drive elite teams.

Sources

The New York Times13h ago

The Athletic Ranks Top 50 Players for 2026 World Cup; Dembele, Kane Lead, Messi, Ronaldo Included

Yahoo Eurosport UK12h ago

Who will win the 2026 World Cup? GOAL writers have their say - Yahoo Sports

khaspress.com14h ago

FIFA World Cup 2026 Power Rankings: All 48 Teams Ranked from 1 to 48 - Khas Press

4 Sources

With legends Messi and Ronaldo ranked low, which football giant is most likely to suffer a shocking group stage exit?

Which rising stars on the list, like Argentina's Nico Paz, are poised for a breakout performance at the World Cup?

Is Dembele's #1 ranking a data anomaly, or has he truly surpassed consistent superstars like Kane and Mbappe?

The Athletic Ranks 50 World Cup Players, Putting Dembele Ahead of Kane and Messi

Summary

Sources

Insights

Related Stories

Sources

Related Stories