The 9 May show featured five matches, with Iyo Sky vs Asuka rated best and Roman Reigns vs Jacob Fatu headlining the card.
USA TODAY Sports gave the event a B+, praising strong performances from Seth Rollins, Bron Breakker and the women's bout for helping reset momentum after WrestleMania 42.
The report said the smaller card gave matches more time to develop, offering WWE a strong start to its new wrestling year even if few bouts may rank among 2026's most memorable.
Is Backlash's lack of rematches a permanent shift in WWE's post-WrestleMania strategy?
After fan backlash over Kairi Sane's release, what is next for WWE's acclaimed women's division?
How will the new fan-voted 'John Cena Classic' reshape WWE's established superstar hierarchy?