Charles McDonald grades all first-round picks in 2026 NFL Draft

4 articles · Updated · Yahoo Sports · Apr 24

McDonald awarded A+ grades to the New York Giants for selecting Arvell Reese and the Washington Commanders for picking Sonny Styles, while the Los Angeles Rams' choice of Ty Simpson received an F.
Other notable evaluations include the Dallas Cowboys' trade-up for Caleb Downs (A+), and critical assessments for the Arizona Cardinals (D for Jeremiyah Love) and Seattle Seahawks (D for Jadarian Price).
The analysis highlights value picks, positional needs, and perceived reaches, providing immediate reactions to each team's draft strategy as the NFL landscape shifts following the first round.

Did QB Ty Simpson's rookie year justify the Rams' controversial 'F' grade pick?

How accurate were 2025's instant A+ and F draft grades one year later?

Did Ohio State's three top-11 defensive picks live up to their elite draft hype?

Has Caleb Downs' performance redefined the value of drafting a safety in the top 15?

After his Heisman season, did Fernando Mendoza meet expectations as the No. 1 pick?

Was drafting a running back third overall truly a mistake for the Arizona Cardinals?