Updated
Updated · The New York Times · Jul 26
Millions Ask Chatbots Moral Questions as A.I. Moves Beyond Right-or-Wrong Answers
Updated
Updated · The New York Times · Jul 26

Millions Ask Chatbots Moral Questions as A.I. Moves Beyond Right-or-Wrong Answers

3 articles · Updated · The New York Times · Jul 26

Summary

  • Millions of users are now asking chatbots to weigh personal and moral dilemmas—whether to divorce, endure painful cancer treatment or sacrifice 1,000 dogs to save one human.
  • Those prompts differ from factual queries because they have no single correct answer, pushing chatbots into gray areas where “right” depends on values rather than verifiable facts.
  • The shift is surfacing in cultural disputes too, including whether it is acceptable to keep listening to Kanye West after antisemitic tirades as concerts are canceled in Britain and France.
  • The broader question is what these systems are drawing on when they answer subjective ethical problems, as A.I. becomes a routine adviser on decisions once left to people.

Insights

If chatbots are programmed to please us, is AI offering genuine moral guidance or just echoing our deepest biases?
With millions secretly asking chatbots whether to end their marriages, who is truly in control of our most intimate human relationships?