Columbia Professor Warns 43% U.S. AI Use Can Make Workers Boring
Updated
Updated · CNBC · Jul 19
Columbia Professor Warns 43% U.S. AI Use Can Make Workers Boring
1 articles · Updated · CNBC · Jul 19
Summary
Sandra Matz said AI can damage careers when workers let it handle critical thinking and creativity, leading to stagnation, mediocrity and what she called “algorithmic consensus.”
43% of U.S. workers already use AI on the job, and Matz said the risk rises because many tools produce safe, obvious answers that make employees “just like everyone else.”
Early-career workers face a bigger threat, Dorothy Leidner said, because they may lack the expertise to use AI as a thought enhancer rather than a thought generator.
Workplace communication is another fault line: Matz said AI-drafted emails and Slack messages can erode trust, while overuse of “digital twins” risks replacing real human exchange.
Several experts said the better use case is narrower—summarizing information, analyzing data and speeding routine tasks—while preserving judgment, creativity, curiosity and relationships as distinctly human value.
Is AI making us more productive but less human at work?
With AI erasing entry-level jobs, how will the next generation ever build a career?
AI promises a trillion-dollar boom, so why are skilled workers losing jobs and hiring freezing?
Half of U.S. Workers Now Use AI: How Rapid Adoption Threatens Individuality, Cognitive Skills, and Innovation
Overview
AI adoption in American workplaces has reached a new high, with half of all employed adults now using AI at least a few times a year, up from 46% last quarter. Daily and weekly use is also rising, and more organizations are integrating AI tools to enhance their practices. This rapid growth is reshaping how people work, raising questions about the impact on worker individuality and cognitive skills. As companies increasingly rely on AI, there is a growing need to balance efficiency with the preservation of human creativity and critical thinking to ensure long-term innovation and competitiveness.