Updated

Updated · Fox News · Jul 14

Chris Simms Ranks Tom Brady 9th All Time as Fans Blast Josh Allen, Lamar Jackson Picks

Updated

Updated · Fox News · Jul 14

Chris Simms Ranks Tom Brady 9th All Time as Fans Blast Josh Allen, Lamar Jackson Picks

Q: Is Chris Simms' controversial QB ranking a genuine football take or just a calculated strategy for media engagement?

It is most likely both: a real football opinion delivered in a way that also maximizes attention. There is evidence Simms is not simply trolling. He has a long record of quarterback evaluation as a former NFL quarterback, ex-Patriots assistant and NBC analyst, and he typically ties rankings to traits such as arm talent, anticipation, athleticism, decision-making and how a player’s peak compares across eras. His preference for Peyton Manning, Patrick Mahomes or Aaron Rodgers over Tom Brady fits a scouting-style framework that values physical tools and peak play independent of career résumé. At the same time, the ranking bears the hallmarks of a media-savvy hot take. Putting Brady at No. 9, elevating Josh Allen and Lamar Jackson above Brady and Dan Marino, and leaving Joe Montana off the list almost guaranteed backlash. In today’s sports media economy, that kind of provocation drives clicks, debate and social engagement, especially on the eve of the NFL season. Simms also works in a format where strong, unconventional opinions are rewarded with visibility. The key point is that those two things are not mutually exclusive. Simms can genuinely believe Brady’s prime was less impressive on pure quarterbacking traits than Manning’s or Mahomes’ while also knowing that publishing such a list will dominate conversation. The available evidence suggests this was not a random stunt, but a sincerely held contrarian view presented in a way that was certain to generate engagement.

1 articles · Updated · Fox News · Jul 14

Tom Brady landed ninth on Chris Simms' all-time quarterback list based on players' primes, with Peyton Manning ranked first and Patrick Mahomes second.
Josh Allen at No. 6 and Lamar Jackson at No. 7 drove much of the backlash, with fans arguing neither belongs ahead of Brady, Dan Marino or other Hall of Famers.
Brady supporters pointed to his 2007 season—4,806 yards, 50 touchdowns and a 16-0 regular season—and his age-44 campaign with 5,316 yards and 43 scores.
The criticism widened beyond Brady's spot, with some users questioning Simms' criteria and others dismissing any top-10 list that omitted Joe Montana.

Sources

Fox News6h ago

Chris Simms' Controversial QB Ranking Places Tom Brady Ninth, Outraging NFL Fans

What specific 'prime' criteria could possibly place current stars like Josh Allen ahead of legends like Tom Brady?

Is Chris Simms' controversial QB ranking a genuine football take or just a calculated strategy for media engagement?

Does the fan outrage over athlete rankings reveal more about the analyst's bias or the audience's own?

Sources

1 total

Fox News6h ago

Chris Simms' Controversial QB Ranking Places Tom Brady Ninth, Outraging NFL Fans

Chris Simms Ranks Tom Brady 9th All Time as Fans Blast Josh Allen, Lamar Jackson Picks

Summary

Sources

Insights

Related Stories

Sources

Related Stories