Updated
Updated · The Daily Beast · Jun 30
Nina Totenberg Apologizes for False Alito Retirement Report, Calling It Worst Error in 50 Years
Updated
Updated · The Daily Beast · Jun 30

Nina Totenberg Apologizes for False Alito Retirement Report, Calling It Worst Error in 50 Years

3 articles · Updated · The Daily Beast · Jun 30

Summary

  • Nina Totenberg, 82, said on NPR’s All Things Considered that the erroneous report of Justice Samuel Alito’s retirement was “entirely” her fault and apologized directly to the 76-year-old justice.
  • A misheard phrase triggered the mistake: after rushing from the Supreme Court, Totenberg said she heard “retirement announcements” and missed the final “s,” leading her to assume Alito was retiring.
  • NPR said the story was online only a few minutes before editors replaced it with a note retracting the report and stating that Alito had not announced any retirement.
  • The episode unfolded during Tuesday’s landmark opinion releases and underscored how quickly an unconfirmed Supreme Court report can spread through Washington newsrooms.

Insights

Can a news outlet's swift and public apology for a major error actually help restore public trust?
How can a veteran reporter's trusted status accidentally become a newsroom's single point of failure?