Updated
Updated · The Independent · Jun 30
DC Admits Supergirl Missed Expectations After $63 Million Opening as Toy Story 5 Led With $70 Million
Updated
Updated · The Independent · Jun 30

DC Admits Supergirl Missed Expectations After $63 Million Opening as Toy Story 5 Led With $70 Million

3 articles · Updated · The Independent · Jun 30

Summary

  • $63 million in its opening weekend left Supergirl below DC Studios' expectations, prompting co-chair Peter Safran to call the result only one part of a longer-term franchise plan.
  • Critics and audiences both cooled on the film: the $170 million production holds a 54% Rotten Tomatoes score, a sharp comedown from James Gunn's Superman, which opened to $125 million in 2025.
  • The weak debut also came amid tougher theater competition, with Disney and Pixar's Toy Story 5 staying No. 1 on $70 million in its second weekend.
  • DC now turns to October release Clayface, which carries a much smaller $40 million budget as the studio presses ahead with its broader universe strategy.

Insights

Will Supergirl's box office disaster force DC to scrap its ambitious universe plans before they've even begun?
Was Supergirl doomed by a bad script, audience fatigue, or the star's controversial promotional tour?