Supergirl Opens in Theaters With a Small-Scale Adventure, Defying Universe-Saving Superhero Formula

3 articles · Updated · IndieWire · Jun 29

"Supergirl" is now in theaters, arriving as a more contained DC story centered on Kara Zor-El rather than another save-the-universe spectacle.
Craig Gillespie’s film narrows the stakes to a personal journey, adapting "Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow" into a character-focused adventure led by Milly Alcock.
The release lands amid debate over its opening-weekend performance and claims that the movie feels formulaic or boring despite strong praise for its smaller scope.
The broader argument is that superhero movies may need to get smaller as audience fatigue grows with franchise entries built around ever-larger, universe-threatening stakes.

Sources

Why did a 'refreshing' personal story for Supergirl result in a film critics called a 'miserable failure'?

Did audiences reject Supergirl's darker story or its controversial changes to Superman's classic heroic origin?

After Supergirl's box office disaster, is James Gunn's entire DC Universe reboot already in jeopardy?