Updated
Updated · Variety · Jun 21
Paget Brewster Apologizes After Telling Critic to Quit Over 10-Episode 'Criminal Minds' Review
Updated
Updated · Variety · Jun 21

Paget Brewster Apologizes After Telling Critic to Quit Over 10-Episode 'Criminal Minds' Review

3 articles · Updated · Variety · Jun 21

Summary

  • Paget Brewster said Sunday she "profoundly" regretted insulting ScreenRant journalist Shealyn Scott on X, apologizing directly after a since-deleted post attacking Scott for doing her job.
  • The clash began after Scott criticized changes in Paramount+'s "Criminal Minds: Evolution," including its 10-episode season structure, which she argued undercut strengths of the long-running procedural.
  • Brewster had told Scott she "suck[s]" and should "work at a shelter," while arguing that bad reviews and pictures can cost 350 people their jobs.
  • Film and TV critics, including The Hollywood Reporter's David Rooney and ScreenRant senior writer Andy Behbakht, publicly condemned Brewster's comments and demanded an apology.
  • "Criminal Minds" ended its original 15-season CBS run in 2020 and was revived by Paramount+ in 2022 as "Criminal Minds: Evolution," the version at the center of Scott's review.

Insights

Are bad reviews the real threat to TV jobs, or does a bigger industry problem loom?
When a star attacks a critic, who really holds the power in Hollywood's new streaming era?