Updated
Updated · The Drive · Jun 20
BMW Toronto Honors C$27,162.79 X3 Offer After AI Chatbot Error
Updated
Updated · The Drive · Jun 20

BMW Toronto Honors C$27,162.79 X3 Offer After AI Chatbot Error

3 articles · Updated · The Drive · Jun 20

Summary

  • BMW Toronto reinstated a C$27,162.79 offer to buy back a customer’s 2021 BMW X3 after initially saying the quote from its chatbot “Quinn” was invalid.
  • A human employee’s miscommunication caused the bot to mistake Zach Giacomelli’s loan balance for the dealership’s purchase price, while a salesperson later said the real offer was only about C$20,000.
  • CBC News’ inquiry prompted the dealership to reverse course, with sales manager Scott Shadbolt saying it chose to “do right” by the customer.
  • Canadian precedent has put companies on the hook for chatbot mistakes; CBC noted Air Canada was forced in 2024 to honor a fare rebate after its bot gave incorrect information.

Insights

As AI replaces jobs, will the cost of its mistakes outweigh the salary savings?
If a chatbot offers a deal, is it now a legally binding contract?
When an AI makes a costly error, where does corporate responsibility legally end?