Trailing after the first tally, how did a unique voting system propel a second-place candidate to a decisive primary victory?

Question

Accepted Answer

Maine’s ranked-choice voting system allowed Matt Dunlap to turn an initial deficit into a clear win by collecting enough backup support from voters whose top choices were eliminated. After the first tally in the Democratic primary for Maine’s 2nd Congressional District, Joe Baldacci led with 31.6% of first-choice votes. Dunlap was second at 29.3%, narrowly ahead of Jordan Wood at 28.8%, while Paige Loud had 10.3%. Because no candidate won a majority, Maine’s ranked-choice rules required an instant runoff. Under that system, the last-place candidate is eliminated and those ballots are reassigned to each voter’s next-ranked remaining choice. The process repeats until one candidate passes 50% of active ballots. That meant the race was not decided by the initial plurality, but by which candidate had broader support across the field. Dunlap benefited when lower-finishing candidates’ supporters had ranked him ahead of Baldacci in later preferences. Once Loud was eliminated and ballots were redistributed, and then Wood’s votes were reassigned in the next round, Dunlap gained enough transferred support to overtake Baldacci and secure a majority. The result showed the central feature of ranked-choice voting: a candidate can lose the opening count but still win if he is the stronger second or third choice for more voters. In this case, Dunlap’s coalition proved wider than Baldacci’s once the field was narrowed, producing a decisive victory after the runoff tabulation concluded early F…

Matt Dunlap Wins Maine 2nd Primary After $500,000 PAC Boost

Sources

Sources

Matt Dunlap Wins Maine 2nd Primary After $500,000 PAC Boost

Summary

Sources

Insights

Related Stories

Sources

Related Stories