Updated
Updated · Fox News · Jun 17
Hasan Piker Says Israel Lacks Right to Exist Since 1948 in Current Form
Updated
Updated · Fox News · Jun 17

Hasan Piker Says Israel Lacks Right to Exist Since 1948 in Current Form

2 articles · Updated · Fox News · Jun 17

Summary

  • Hasan Piker told "The Breakfast Club" that Israel has no right to exist "in its current formation," framing his answer as a critique of the state’s political structure rather than its people.
  • Asked whether Israel and a Palestinian state both have a right to exist, Piker compared Israel’s current form to Nazi Germany, apartheid South Africa and Rhodesia, saying such regimes had no right to continue.
  • Piker said the phrase "right to exist" is used to deflect attention from Israel’s treatment of Palestinians and to portray critics as calling for the extermination of Jews or Israelis.
  • Jerry Seinfeld’s recent "It doesn’t exist" reply to a "Free Palestine" prompt sparked the exchange; Piker called Seinfeld racist and argued Palestine predates Israel, which he noted was founded in 1948.

Insights

How can one distinguish between criticism of a state and the antisemitism Hasan Piker is accused of?
Do international court rulings on apartheid validate controversial critiques of Israel's right to exist?