Updated
Updated · The Associated Press · Jun 15
FIFA Clears World Cup Official Shaun Evans Over 1 Hand Gesture as He Blames Twitch
Updated
Updated · The Associated Press · Jun 15

FIFA Clears World Cup Official Shaun Evans Over 1 Hand Gesture as He Blames Twitch

3 articles · Updated · The Associated Press · Jun 15

Summary

  • FIFA’s independent disciplinary committee found no breach by Australian video review official Shaun Evans after his on-camera hand sign before Germany’s 7-1 win over Curaçao drew scrutiny.
  • Evans said the gesture was an involuntary, subconscious twitch, not an intentional message, and said later images showed him repeating the movement while holding a pen.
  • Fare, FIFA’s anti-discrimination monitoring partner, said the upside-down “OK” sign resembled a white power symbol and had urged that Evans be removed from the tournament.
  • The symbol was added to the Anti-Defamation League’s hate-symbol database in 2019, though the group has said context is key because the gesture also has harmless uses.

Insights

Why was a World Cup official cleared for a gesture that has ended careers for others?
When a simple 'OK' sign is also a hate symbol, how can we ever truly know the intent?