Updated
Updated · The New York Times · Jun 10
Appeals Court Blocks Alabama Nitrogen Execution of Jeffrey Lee, Calling Method Likely Unconstitutional
Updated
Updated · The New York Times · Jun 10

Appeals Court Blocks Alabama Nitrogen Execution of Jeffrey Lee, Calling Method Likely Unconstitutional

3 articles · Updated · The New York Times · Jun 10

Summary

  • A federal appeals court on Wednesday let stand an order barring Alabama from using nitrogen hypoxia to execute Jeffrey Lee, whose execution had been scheduled for Thursday.
  • The 11th Circuit backed U.S. District Judge Emily Marks, saying nitrogen hypoxia is a “likely unconstitutional method” of carrying out the death penalty.
  • Marks had initially allowed nitrogen gas nearly two weeks ago, but the appeals court sent the case back and she then ruled for Lee after finding a firing squad could render him unconscious before pain registered.
  • Alabama had argued it lacks both legislative approval and an operational firing-squad protocol, including five qualified marksmen, leaving the state to find another method if it still plans to proceed.

Insights

A court has blocked nitrogen gas executions. Could this ruling end the method's use nationwide?
Why would a court rule a firing squad is more humane than execution by nitrogen gas?