Updated

Updated · The Verge · Jun 10

The Verge Reviewer Picks $170 Soundcore Liberty 5 Pro as Top Earbuds Over 2 Rivals

Updated

Updated · The Verge · Jun 10

The Verge Reviewer Picks $170 Soundcore Liberty 5 Pro as Top Earbuds Over 2 Rivals

Q: Apple's AirPods Pro 3 offer unmatched noise cancellation, but does a critical design flaw make them unusable for workouts?

No. The reporting does not support calling the AirPods Pro 3 “unusable” for workouts, but it does show a meaningful fit problem for some users. In the original review, the key issue was not noise cancellation or durability. The reviewer praised the AirPods Pro 3 for class-leading ANC, strong sound, seamless Apple-device switching, and an IP57 rating. The problem was fit: they said the earbuds still came loose during workouts and that the stem design was awkward to manage while moving. That was enough for this reviewer to stop using them for exercise and switch to the Beats Powerbeats Fit. The broader material points in two directions. Some sources describe Apple as having improved the fit, stability, ear tips, and workout features, including heart-rate tracking and stronger sweat resistance. That suggests the earbuds are not inherently flawed for exercise and may work well for many people. But the same body of information also notes that secure fit remains user-dependent, and the existence of third-party foam tips aimed at preventing slippage reinforces that this is a real concern. So the practical answer is that the AirPods Pro 3 are not broadly unusable for workouts, but they can be a poor workout choice if their shape does not lock into your ears securely. For buyers who prioritize exercise stability over ANC, the reviewer’s evidence favors the Beats Powerbeats Fit.

3 articles · Updated · The Verge · Jun 10

$170 Soundcore Liberty 5 Pro emerged as the reviewer's top pick among three earbuds he says he uses most often after 20 years covering audio gear.
Call quality drove that ranking: the earbuds blocked heavy ambient noise on calls, while ANC was described as comparable to pricier Apple AirPods Pro 3 and sound improved after app-based EQ tuning.
The tradeoffs were shorter battery life at 6.5 hours with ANC on, support for only two connected devices at once, and a default tuning the reviewer said needs adjustment.
Apple AirPods Pro 3 remained the easier choice inside Apple's ecosystem, while Beats Powerbeats Fit were favored for workouts because their wingtip design stayed secure during runs.
If forced to choose just one pair, the reviewer said the Soundcore model stood out for combining the lowest price of the three with strong sound, versatility and standout calling performance.