Updated
Updated · Fox News · Jun 7
Smoltz Backs 2-Challenge ABS but Warns Full-Time Automation Will Make Baseball Suffer
Updated
Updated · Fox News · Jun 7

Smoltz Backs 2-Challenge ABS but Warns Full-Time Automation Will Make Baseball Suffer

1 articles · Updated · Fox News · Jun 7

Summary

  • John Smoltz called MLB’s ABS challenge system a “big success” one month into the season, but said baseball would “suffer” if every pitch were ruled by automation.
  • Two challenges per team is the right limit, Smoltz said, arguing a full-time automated zone would make hitting “impossible” and change the sport too drastically.
  • Fangraphs data already show a shift in play: hitters are swinging at 46.9% of pitches this season versus 47.5% last year, while walk rate has risen to 9.2% from 8.4%.
  • Smoltz tied that change partly to pitchers losing borderline calls they once got, saying hitters, catchers and teams are adjusting quickly to the challenge-based system.

Insights

How has the ABS challenge system changed the psychological game between pitchers and hitters on the mound?
As ABS data uncovers umpire bias, is the argument for keeping the 'human element' in baseball collapsing?