Updated
Updated · The New York Times · Jun 3
Mullin Opens Path to Costa Rica Deportation for Abrego Garcia, Reversing 1-Year Standoff
Updated
Updated · The New York Times · Jun 3

Mullin Opens Path to Costa Rica Deportation for Abrego Garcia, Reversing 1-Year Standoff

1 articles · Updated · The New York Times · Jun 3

Summary

  • Tuesday’s congressional testimony from Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin indicated Kilmar Abrego Garcia could be deported to Costa Rica if he agrees, a sharp shift from the administration’s earlier refusals.
  • Costa Rica has been Abrego Garcia’s preferred destination for months, and his lawyers have said sending him there would end his long-running legal fight with the Trump administration.
  • His attorneys quickly filed Mullin’s remarks with Judge Paula Xinis, the Maryland federal judge who has repeatedly pressed the government on why Costa Rica was not an option.
  • The reversal’s scope remains unclear: Mullin may have changed department policy, or he may have been unaware of prior efforts to deport Abrego Garcia to African countries instead.
  • Abrego Garcia’s case has become a high-profile test of Trump’s deportation agenda since his wrongful March 2025 expulsion to El Salvador, where he was jailed and said he was tortured.

Insights

When a DHS Secretary and his lawyers state conflicting deportation plans, whose policy will a federal judge follow?
Can one public comment from a new cabinet secretary upend years of legal strategy in a landmark immigration case?