Updated
Updated · The Guardian · Jun 9
Caraway’s $155 3qt Saute Pan Impresses in Tests, Though Stainless Steel Still Sears Better
Updated
Updated · The Guardian · Jun 9

Caraway’s $155 3qt Saute Pan Impresses in Tests, Though Stainless Steel Still Sears Better

3 articles · Updated · The Guardian · Jun 9

Summary

  • $155 Caraway’s new 3-quart saute pan delivered strong nonstick results in testing, with onions sliding out cleanly and chicken thighs moving easily even with no added oil.
  • Seven minutes was enough to bring 1 quart of water to a rolling boil on medium heat, while the pan’s tall sides contained simmering curry well and prevented spillovers.
  • At 5.5 pounds, the pan was manageable but needed two hands to fully tilt for pouring; both the main and helper handles heated up quickly, though the lid handle stayed cooler longer.
  • Ceramic coating remained the main trade-off: the sear on chicken was somewhat uneven, and the reviewer said no ceramic pan matches stainless steel for responsiveness and all-over browning.
  • Three quarts was framed as a practical middle size—enough for four to six chicken thighs or a steak with greens—making the pan a better fit for everyday home cooks than for performance-focused buyers.

Insights

With a short lifespan but a 'nontoxic' promise, is Caraway's cookware the future or a costly compromise?
Caraway touts cookware safety while rivals sue for false advertising. Who should consumers trust in this toxic debate?